View Full Version: Opinions on Snape and Malfoy

The Leaky Cauldron > The Half-Blood Prince > Opinions on Snape and Malfoy



Title: Opinions on Snape and Malfoy
Description: Are they going to turn good.


jyo226 - July 19, 2005 03:21 PM (GMT)
I ask because it seems confusing that Dumbledore would have been wrong in trusting Snape for sixteen years and Dumble dore was rarely wrong. I wonder if he had it arranged with Snape to kill him as a means to carry on the ruse of Snape being with Voldemort. You know for the greater good and everything. Also, why did Malfoy have such a hard time killing Dumbledore. I've kind of wondered all along if there was a side to Malfoy that is not obvious. I think deep down he admires Harry but feels threatened by him.

Kitty - July 19, 2005 03:23 PM (GMT)
But don't you remember that he said him being slightly more intellegent and all that his mistakes were much bigger. Sorry if I said that wrong...

jyo226 - July 19, 2005 03:31 PM (GMT)
The ending of the book seriously has me baffled. I think that there will be a lot of big surprises in the next book. I absolutely think that Draco is a jealous brat but I wonder if Snape/Narcissa will have some sort of disenchantmet with Voldemort. Snape may have already. Also, with Lucius gone Draco may be persuaded to join with Harry.

Merlin - July 19, 2005 03:46 PM (GMT)
i want snape and malfoy to die it was malfoys fault he let the death eaters in

Kitty - July 19, 2005 07:52 PM (GMT)
Gah they're both slimey evil gits with so much grime in their hair they could drown all Hogwarts in it! :angry:


Sorry, I'm going into my mad mood again! <_<

Shonk Da 'Onk - July 21, 2005 08:08 AM (GMT)
*rolls eyes at grumpy peeps*

Remeber now peeps...ITS A BOOK *nods*

Anywayz...I don't think Sevy Poo is a baddy but I don't know about Malfoy ^_^

Merlin - July 21, 2005 03:51 PM (GMT)
im not grumpy im fine just stayting a point

Kitty - July 21, 2005 03:53 PM (GMT)
Gah! The evil slimeballs... :angry: <_<

FISH - July 21, 2005 11:45 PM (GMT)
ok i think that Malfoy isnt entirely evil becuase he loved his parents so much that he didnt want em to die....if he was a true death eater then he would take a second glance if his parents were having their anterils cut out and burned. and he didnt kno if he should kill DD and he couldnt kill him.....ok he only went along was becuase he was scared and becuase he wanted to save his family.

SiRiUsLyAdDiCtEd - July 23, 2005 02:14 AM (GMT)
i don't think snape's on voldemort's side.

malfoy? not sure. i mean we've always known his opinion about muggle-borns and we know he was very proud his father is a death-eater. i'm also not 100% sure on that, but i thought J.K> had said before that malfoy was not gonna turn good? not sure. i think he wants to be a big death-eater bully, wants to be like his daddy (unless he's changed his mind when daddy got thrown into azkaban....didn't get the impression at the end of OotP tho) ....but when it comes to it he's too afraid of going through with it. he doesn't have what it takes to be a death eater!
(and that's a good thing! means he's at least got some kind of - how the heck do you write that word??? - concience! (i think that's it) he's got maybe even a little bit of heart :wub: ...lol. - don't let daddy hear that :firedevil: - but maybe it was a bit much to ask to kill Dumbledore, come on! if he maybe was ordered to kill ron, harry or hermione he might have been able to )

Merlin - July 23, 2005 02:17 PM (GMT)
you do know taht harry will want to kill snape and malfoy now because they killed DD and DD was like the farther harry never had when he was little because james died DD has been there right through hogwarts for harry he stood by him all the time

mwiley - July 28, 2005 11:52 PM (GMT)
Well I think Sirius was kinda the father he never had in a way too...he was a lot like james, so for harry it was probably almost like knowing his real father.

But anyway..Harry will want to kill snape for killing dumbledore definatly. I mean harry was really close to the headmaster...and dumbledore was the only one that could give him information on vodemort too, now he has to do it on his own and cope with another death of someone that he was close too. In their different ways I think both sirius and dumledore were like a father to harry and now they're both gone..harry's gonna want revenge on vodemort and all his death eaters, there's no doubt he will.

hot - December 26, 2007 02:46 AM (GMT)
I hope that at this point this question answers itself because all of you should have read the last book at this point....
*glares at anyone who hasn't done so yet*




Hosted for free by InvisionFree