View Full Version: Why does harry leave the dursleys' early?

The Leaky Cauldron > The Half-Blood Prince > Why does harry leave the dursleys' early?



Title: Why does harry leave the dursleys' early?
Description: besides that he hates it there :P


SiRiUsLyAdDiCtEd - February 22, 2005 05:37 AM (GMT)
as so often, i'm going to start this off with a JK quote :P . here Jo squashed a rumour and left us guessing ....

Rumour:
QUOTE
Harry stands trial again in HP&THBP


What Jo said:
QUOTE
This theory has been put forward to explain why Harry does not spend as long in Privet Drive during this book as previous ones, but I am happy to say that he leaves the Dursleys early for a much pleasanter reason than a court case.


k, there it is :) it's gonna be harry's shortest stay yet and it's because of something good (cause Jo's happy :D ). i don't have very many ideas on this either, but there's one i actually really like!! maybe there'll be a weasley wedding? maybe bill and fleur are getting married?

any thoughts? different ideas? i'ld LOVE to hear them!

hermionefan4life - February 22, 2005 01:21 PM (GMT)
thats kool that something good is gonna happen! but i have no idea on what it might be....

CheerTwisters13 - February 22, 2005 04:43 PM (GMT)
I don't know what it might be.. but I think tghat its about time something GOOD happens to Harry, I mean like everything bad happened to him in the 5th book... it was really depressing actually!

Phoenix - February 22, 2005 09:37 PM (GMT)
I CRIED reading that book! when Bellatrix the *itch got sirius
it was so sad! i really was shook up about it i loved him he was a great character.

Luna - March 16, 2005 04:12 PM (GMT)
I think the wedding is a good idea. Hmmm, wat else could happen? Maybe he goes to visit Dumbledore? I kno that's farfetched and unlikly, but really why not?! Maybe he's gonns learn some advanced defensive spells!

flounder21 - March 16, 2005 08:42 PM (GMT)
hmmm i dont no. maybe the weassleys could adopt him or somethin? or maybe he got invited 2 somethin really important like the world cup or somethin. i dont no! :blink:

Phoenix - March 16, 2005 11:16 PM (GMT)
QUOTE (Luna @ Mar 16 2005, 09:12 AM)
I think the wedding is a good idea. Hmmm, wat else could happen? Maybe he goes to visit Dumbledore? I kno that's farfetched and unlikly, but really why not?! Maybe he's gonns learn some advanced defensive spells!

i like this theory anna! it is actually quite possible considering he was getting private occlumency lessons from snape and DD did say he regretted not teaching him himself. but maybe it has got somthin to do with the weasleys - though i think a wedding is unlikely

SiRiUsLyAdDiCtEd - March 18, 2005 06:21 AM (GMT)
i also think it's very possible and not far fetched at all. the thing is, i can't imagine harry staying with DD. and DD will be way too busy. but you know who would be a great person to teach him some more stuff? how about our dear Lupin? i think that would make harry happy :).

i'm not sure about the weasleys. they are the poeple he is closest to and they've been inviting him over a lot, but they don't seem to be the right poeple to teach him advanced defensive spells and such - and i have to say i'm liking this idea a lot! they are both in the order tho, so they would be able to teach him, but they wouldn't be the best choice imo.

Professor Rogue - March 18, 2005 07:06 AM (GMT)
A wedding would defaintly qualify as a pleasant reason, I agree. But whose? I have no idea on that one!

But who knows? Maybe Harry is going to be made into Head Boy or something and he needs to get to school early so that they can teach him or something? I dunno. Do you think that he'll go to Hogwarts early, or somewhere else?

Lianslo - March 18, 2005 08:45 AM (GMT)
I'm putting my money on somewhere else. I really like the Lupin idea as well. The two of them get along great, plus - like Bianca said he could definately teach Harry a thing or two!

Luna - March 18, 2005 04:13 PM (GMT)
Yeah, Lupin seems good. I don't think it's very likely that he'll go to hogwarts. But then again, isn't he suppose to be the safest there? Maybe he's suppose to go stay with Hagrid. Wasn't there a rumor that said: "someone who didn't know magic well before will learn more" or something. Couldn't that be Hagrid? If he learns proper magic then he'll be good protection! He's fiesty, big, strong AND magical.

hermionefan4life - March 18, 2005 05:55 PM (GMT)
QUOTE (Luna @ Mar 18 2005, 11:13 AM)
Yeah, Lupin seems good. I don't think it's very likely that he'll go to hogwarts. But then again, isn't he suppose to be the safest there? Maybe he's suppose to go stay with Hagrid. Wasn't there a rumor that said: "someone who didn't know magic well before will learn more" or something. Couldn't that be Hagrid? If he learns proper magic then he'll be good protection! He's fiesty, big, strong AND magical.

good point. he could be going to see hagrid. that would be cool.

and going to see lupin would also be good. But I don't think he will go back to hogwarts early.

as for the marriage, that would be cool. But who would get married? i guess there are lots of things that could be happy.....I just want to read the book! lol

SiRiUsLyAdDiCtEd - March 18, 2005 06:49 PM (GMT)
noone seems to have read my first post cause everyone is asking who would get married :P
i was thinking maybe bill and fleur could get married, but i like the newer ideas better.
i have to say i also like harry going to hagrid's a lot!! never thought about that before.


hermionefan4life - March 18, 2005 07:11 PM (GMT)
yah, bill and fleur could get married, that would be awesome.

Luna - March 18, 2005 07:46 PM (GMT)
QUOTE (SiRiUsLyAdDiCtEd @ Mar 18 2005, 12:49 PM)
noone seems to have read my first post cause everyone is asking who would get married :P
i was thinking maybe bill and fleur could get married, but i like the newer ideas better.
i have to say i also like harry going to hagrid's a lot!! never thought about that before.

Hey! I read it. I think it's still possible that thosee two get married.
Oh another version that came to me as i was cleaning yesterday: The Joke Shop. I mean Fred and George never had a proper opening day did they?
So they could decide to have a formal opening and invite Harry to it. I know that's unlikely but after all, it's plausible!

Hehe, thanx for liking my ideas so far!

SiRiUsLyAdDiCtEd - March 21, 2005 05:52 AM (GMT)
yes yes yes!!! you guys are coming up with all kinds of great ideas :). way better than my marriage idea and a lot more possible/probable.

i love the joke shop idea too! now i can't decide between the two (joke shop and going somewhere to learn DADA). maybe first he goes to the grand opening for the joke shop and then he goes to the weasleys' (or lupin's :D) to learn DADA :D

this is going to be so great when we finally get to read the book and see if any of us got it right! 116 days to go!!!!

Coldfire - March 21, 2005 06:18 AM (GMT)
Bill and Fleur getting married? I don't think it very likely. The Joke Shop official opening? I dunno about that one either. Going to Lupin's to learn DADA, well that idea kinda appeals to me. . . that would be cool, and Lupin is a real neat guy!!

BarbieGirl - March 21, 2005 07:16 AM (GMT)
I think Harry is just going to go and stay with the Weasleys. Or maybe he will be going to Grimmauld Place for some reason???

Luna - March 21, 2005 01:30 PM (GMT)
ooooooh! #12 Grimauld place?!
Mayb it's some way to talk to sirius! that would be pleasant! good idea ash!

Lupin231 - March 21, 2005 08:53 PM (GMT)
Perhaps Proffessar Magonagall is going to coach him like se said in OTP
I know it is unlikely but yet still possible.

But i like the idea of the official opening of the twins shop

darko-grl - March 28, 2005 06:37 AM (GMT)
QUOTE (Lupin231 @ Mar 21 2005, 01:53 PM)
Perhaps Proffessar Magonagall is going to coach him like se said in OTP
I know it is unlikely but yet still possible.

But i like the idea of the official opening of the twins shop

I wouldn't blame him for leaving, I would sooooo leave.

I think that Prof Mg, will help him out with his studies etc...

whiteflame - March 28, 2005 03:43 PM (GMT)
QUOTE (flounder21 @ Mar 16 2005, 03:42 PM)
hmmm i dont no. maybe the weassleys could adopt him or somethin? or maybe he got invited 2 somethin really important like the world cup or somethin. i dont no! :blink:

i know im late on this one here. but flounder that is not possible. in the fourth book he got invited to the world cup. and they also said that it only happened every four years. i think Jo planned this so that she wouldnt have to think up something to happen again at the it. and it would be repitive.

maybe its because *HOPEFULLY* sirius *HOPEFULLY* gets to come back. then he leaves to go see his fave uncle.

really hopeful thinking there though.

Coldfire - March 29, 2005 07:10 AM (GMT)
Unfortunately, I have to agree with whiteflame. It doesn't look very promising that Sirius is gonna come back. But that doesn't mean we can't hope!! And the Quidditch World Cup is right too; it would be repetitive. I think he's either gonna get tutored by a teacher (like McGonagall to become an Auror, or Snape for Occlumency), which he could do at Grimmauld Place, or he's going to stay at the Weasley's again.

whiteflame - March 29, 2005 05:23 PM (GMT)
thats true coldfire. i think we shouldnt give up hope. i mean, there was no mention of the people saying that they studied and they were completely dead. and what i was thinking, why didnt harry just roll the other mirror into the veil? i mean, people and clothes and things go in there, so why cant a mirror just be rolled in there.

i dont think hed go see a teacher tho. maybe he would sneak away, and live with fred and george and help them with the shop. or something like that

OR

he could sneak away to hermiones house and marry her likes their supposed to! lol

Coldfire - March 30, 2005 03:48 AM (GMT)
QUOTE (whiteflame @ Mar 29 2005, 10:23 AM)
thats true coldfire. i think we shouldnt give up hope. i mean, there was no mention of the people saying that they studied and they were completely dead. and what i was thinking, why didnt harry just roll the other mirror into the veil? i mean, people and clothes and things go in there, so why cant a mirror just be rolled in there.

i dont think hed go see a teacher tho. maybe he would sneak away, and live with fred and george and help them with the shop. or something like that

OR

he could sneak away to hermiones house and marry her likes their supposed to! lol

That is a really good point whiteflame!! :o Wow, I can't believe that I didn't think of that!!!

Yeah, I'm not really going for the teacher thing, but I thought I'd suggest it anyways. He should totally go and live with Fred and George. I mean, he could help them, and why not? He gave them the money to start it in the first place, after all. But Harry sneaking over to Hermione's and marrying her?? lol, I don't think that's gonna be happening too soon! :D :lol:

Luna - March 30, 2005 01:33 PM (GMT)
It'd be really cool if he snuk off to marry hermy, but i don't think it's gonna happen.
It'd be nice if he went and lived with the twins too! Dang, I WANNA READ!

mwiley - April 1, 2005 06:58 PM (GMT)
QUOTE (Luna @ Mar 18 2005, 09:13 AM)
Yeah, Lupin seems good. I don't think it's very likely that he'll go to hogwarts. But then again, isn't he suppose to be the safest there? Maybe he's suppose to go stay with Hagrid. Wasn't there a rumor that said: "someone who didn't know magic well before will learn more" or something. Couldn't that be Hagrid? If he learns proper magic then he'll be good protection! He's fiesty, big, strong AND magical.

Thats what i was thinking when i read that one!! Hagrid!! The thing is, if harry was living with lupin, well lupins not very wealthy, and i don't think he'd accept any of harry's money, but it would be cool if he got to live with lupin. The wedding thing, would be interesting, but not likely, man there are alot of good suggestions in here!! i should have posted earlier.




Hosted for free by InvisionFree